Blake Lively

(Lily Bloom)

Justin Baldoni

(Ryle Kincaid)

Jenny Slate

(Allysa)

Brandon Sklenar

(Atlas Corrigan)

Hasan Minhaj

(Marshall)

Kevin McKidd

(Andrew Bloom)

Amy Morton

(Jenny Bloom)

Alex Neustaedter

(Young Atlas Corrigan)

Isabela Ferrer

(Young Lily Bloom)

Robert Clohessy

(Sheriff)

Robin S. Walker

(Doctor Johnson)

Emily Baldoni

(Doctor Julie)

Adam Mondschein

(Doctor Dunbar)

Caroline Siegrist

(Katie)

Robyn Lively

(Ms. Byland)

Megan Robinson

(Ms. Smith)

Steve Monroe

(Realtor)

Daphne Zelle

(Female Waiter)